A foundation crack does not stop you from selling a plex. What lowers the price is uncertainty: a buyer who doesn't know whether the crack is moving will price in the worst case. Your job comes down to three steps: get the crack assessed, disclose what you know in writing, then choose between repairing, adjusting the price or selling as-is. At ImmoMulti, we buy plexes with foundation work ahead. We factor it into the offer, and that's it.
Shrinkage crack or structural crack: what the buyer wants to know
The first question isn't "is it serious?" but "what kind of crack is it, and is it still moving?". That is exactly what the buyer's inspector, then their lender, will try to establish.
A shrinkage crack appears as concrete dries. It is usually thin, vertical and stable. It may let a little moisture through, but on its own it does not threaten the structure. A structural crack comes from forces on the foundation: soil movement, water pressure against a poorly drained wall, freeze-thaw, overload.
| Sign | Generally reassuring | Have an engineer look at it |
|---|---|---|
| Direction | Vertical | Horizontal, diagonal or stair-step in a block wall |
| Opening | Thin, even | Open, wider at one end |
| Change over time | Stable | Getting longer or wider |
| Nearby signs | None | Bulging wall, sloping floor, sticking doors |
| Water | None, or an old issue that was fixed | Repeated basement leaks |
This table points you in a direction; it is not a diagnosis. For a typical crack, a building inspector's pre-sale inspection gives you a first opinion. If any sign in the right-hand column is present, call a structural engineer who is a member of the Ordre des ingénieurs du Québec. The report costs money, but it replaces an unknown with a diagnosis and a list of fixes.
Before you call anyone
- Photograph the crack with a ruler beside it, and date the photo.
- Mark both ends in pencil with the date. Check again after a few weeks.
- Write down the history: leaks, repairs, French drain replacement, with invoices.
What you must disclose to the buyer
Everything you know: the crack, past leaks, repairs made and reports received. A repaired crack must be disclosed too, with the invoice and warranty.
In Québec, the sale of a building carries a legal warranty of quality under the Civil Code. The seller warrants the buyer against latent (hidden) defects: a serious defect that existed at the time of sale, that the buyer did not know about and could not have found through a careful inspection. A defect you disclosed in writing is no longer hidden from the buyer. That is your best protection.
If you sell through a broker, the OACIQ's Declarations by the Seller form is mandatory for a mainly residential building with fewer than five dwellings. Without a broker, it is not required, but your duty to inform the buyer still applies. Make a written, dated and signed declaration with the documents attached.
Don't cover anything up
Painting or parging a foundation wall right before showings, or hiding a water stain behind boxes, can be seen as concealment. That kind of move is what turns an ordinary crack into a lawsuit.
A sale can be made "without legal warranty, at the buyer's own risk" if the promise to purchase and the deed of sale say so. The clause reduces your exposure, but according to Éducaloi it generally does not protect a seller who knew about a defect and did not reveal it. It does not replace disclosure. Have your notary draft it. Our guide on latent defects and the legal warranty covers these rules in detail.
Sources: Éducaloi — Latent defects in a building; Éducaloi — La garantie légale (in French); OACIQ — Declarations by the Seller form. For your situation, consult a notary or a lawyer.
The effect on price and on the buyer's financing
The buyer takes the estimated cost of the work off the price, plus a margin for what they don't know. The clearer your file, the smaller that margin.
A stable, documented shrinkage crack carries little weight in a negotiation. An active or structural crack gets negotiated. The buyer starts from the repair cost, then adds a cushion for uncertainty: unknown cause, a French drain that may need replacing, hidden damage behind a finished wall. An engineer's report and a written quote bring the discussion back to a number.
As a cautious order of magnitude: injecting a crack from the inside often costs hundreds of dollars, sometimes a few thousand. An exterior repair with excavation, a French drain replacement or pile stabilization is more likely to run into the tens of thousands. Only quotes for your building count.
On the financing side, the buyer's lender may require an engineer's report, hold back part of the loan until the work is done, or refuse to finance a building with an uncorrected structural defect. A deal can therefore fall apart late, at the financing stage, if the crack wasn't explained up front.
Estimate the foundation workAn order of magnitude before you set your price or negotiate →Your three options: repair, adjust the price or sell as-is
1. Repair before selling
This often pays for a shrinkage crack that lets in a little water: an injection deals with the symptom quickly. Keep the invoice and warranty. If the water comes from a clogged drain, downspouts emptying at the foot of the wall or ground sloping toward the building, fix the cause. Otherwise the crack will come back, and the inspector will see it.
2. Disclose and adjust the price
For major work (excavation, drain, piles), you don't have to launch a job site in an occupied building. Get the report and one or two quotes, hand them to the buyer and negotiate on that number. You avoid fronting the money and managing access to the units. Reminder: your tenants are entitled to 24 hours' notice before a visit or inspection.
3. Sell as-is, without legal warranty, to a direct buyer
If you don't want to front the money, wait for the work or depend on a buyer's financing, sell to someone who buys with full knowledge. That's what ImmoMulti does for 2- to 12-unit plexes on the North Shore and in Montréal. We visit, we look at the basement, and we build the cost of the work into the offer. You disclose what you know, and the sale is made without legal warranty, before your notary. See also how to sell an income property that needs renovation, or tell us about your building.