A basement unit built twenty years ago, a fourth unit the zoning doesn't allow, work done without a permit by a previous owner: this is common in older plexes. It can be dealt with, but not by keeping quiet about it.
Non-conforming, derogatory or illegal: what are we talking about?
The words matter, because they lead to different consequences.
- Conforming: the unit meets the current zoning by-law and construction standards.
- Derogatory, protected by acquired rights: the unit no longer meets the current by-law, but it was legal when it was created. It can generally continue to exist.
- Illegal: the unit was created without a permit or against the by-law of the time. It has no acquired rights, and the municipality can require that it be brought into compliance or that the use stop.
Acquired rights can be lost if the use is abandoned or interrupted for the period set in the municipal by-law. Rules vary from city to city: only your municipality can confirm your unit's status. The number of units on the assessment roll does not prove they are authorized.
What you must disclose
The buyer is buying a number of units and an income. If one of the units is not authorized, that information goes straight to value, and you must provide it. Your statements in the promise to purchase about the building's compliance bind you, and a seller who knew about the situation and kept quiet is exposed to a claim after the sale.
Put in writing:
- The number of units rented and the number authorized by the municipality, if you know it.
- Work done without a permit, by you or a previous owner.
- Notices, findings or requests received from the municipality.
- Evidence of the history: old leases, assessment rolls, photos, permits.
With a broker, these items go in the Seller's Declarations form. Without a broker, your notary can include them in the promise to purchase.
The tenant still has a lease
The tenant of the unauthorized unit signed a lease, and the unit's non-conformity does not, on its own, allow you to evict them. If the city requires the use to stop, the buyer inherits a delicate situation. That is one reason they will want to know everything before signing. If a municipal notice is in progress, talk to a lawyer.
The effect on price and on the buyer's financing
The buyer's lender finances what is authorized. It may count only the units recognized by the municipality and leave the rent of the non-conforming unit out of its calculation. If that unit takes the building from four to five units, the file may even move to a different financing category. The insurer may also refuse to cover a unit that does not meet safety standards, such as exits or fire separation.
On price, the buyer therefore starts from the authorized income, then adds part of the unit's value depending on the risk and the cost of regularizing it. The GRM calculator lets you run the numbers with and without the unit.
Illustrative example — fictitious figures
A triplex also rents out a basement unit built without a permit. Gross income: $48,000 per year, of which $9,000 comes from the basement. Applying a gross rent multiplier (GRM) of 13 to the authorized income only ($39,000), a buyer arrives at $507,000, instead of $624,000 on the full income. The $117,000 gap is what the non-conformity puts on the table in the negotiation. These figures describe neither a real case nor a market rule.
Your three options
1. Regularize before selling
If the zoning allows that number of units, it is mainly a matter of getting a permit and bringing the unit up to standard: ceiling height, windows, exits, fire separation, alarms. If the zoning does not allow it, it takes longer. A minor variance cannot cover use or density; you generally need a by-law amendment or another tool provided by the municipality, with no guaranteed outcome. Some cities have relaxed their rules on accessory dwelling units: ask the urban-planning department.
2. Document acquired rights
If the unit existed legally before the current by-law, gather the evidence: old permits, assessment rolls, leases, dated photos, utility bills. Then ask the municipality for written confirmation. One letter from the city is worth more than ten claims in a listing.
3. Sell as-is, with disclosure
You disclose the situation, set a price that reflects it and sell without legal warranty, at the buyer's risk, with a clause drafted by the notary. That clause does not cover what you concealed; see our guide on latent defects and the legal warranty. A direct buyer who knows these files values the building as it is, without requiring regularization before the sale. See also: selling an income property as-is.
ImmoMulti buys non-conforming plexes
One unit too many, a basement without a permit: we are interested in your building. We look at the income, the status of each unit and the condition of the building, then make an offer on the plex as it is, with no broker and no commission. Ask for an offer.
Sources: MAMH — Urban-planning by-laws and acquired rights (in French); Government of Québec — Minor variance by-law (in French).
Informational content only. It does not constitute legal advice. Zoning and acquired-rights rules vary by municipality: consult its urban-planning department, a notary or a lawyer for your situation.