You own a building with apartments upstairs and a business at street level, and you are thinking of selling. The sale works like a plex sale, with three differences: GST and QST can apply to the commercial part, the commercial lease follows different rules from a residential lease, and the buyer has a harder time getting financing, which means fewer buyers. Sort out the tax question with a tax advisor and gather your commercial leases before you look for a buyer.
GST and QST: the commercial part can be taxable
According to Revenu Québec, the sale of a residential building that is not new and has not been substantially renovated is generally exempt from GST and QST. That exemption covers the dwellings. The commercial part of a mixed-use building can be taxable, so the price must be split between the two uses.
This is what surprises mixed-use sellers most. In practice, you allocate the sale price between the value of the dwellings and the value of the commercial unit, on a defensible basis: floor area, income from each part, an appraisal. An allocation improvised at the notary's office can lead to a tax assessment after the sale.
Who pays the tax? When the buyer is registered for GST and QST, the buyer generally reports and remits the tax on the taxable part (self-assessment) instead of the seller collecting it. Your own situation also changes the answer: are you selling personally or through a corporation, are you registered, did you claim input tax credits on the building? Have a tax advisor confirm the treatment before you sign the promise to purchase. Source: Revenu Québec — Sale of residential properties.
Put it in the promise to purchase
State whether the price is "plus applicable taxes" and how it is split between residential and commercial. A price that is silent on taxes leaves an expensive question to settle at the last minute.
Commercial leases: what the buyer will read
A residential lease is governed by the Tribunal administratif du logement and, as a rule, renews automatically. A commercial lease is a freely negotiated contract: it does not renew by itself unless the lease includes an option. On a sale, the buyer takes over the leases, but will read every commercial lease closely.
For the buyer, the commercial unit is the riskiest part of the building. They will check:
- The remaining term and renewal options: a lease ending in six months is a vacancy risk;
- Who pays what: in a gross lease, the landlord pays taxes, insurance and maintenance; in a net lease, the tenant reimburses some or all of them;
- Assignment and sublease clauses, and any deposit paid by the tenant;
- Registration in the land register: a registered commercial lease better protects the tenant against a new owner. If it is not registered, the Civil Code allows the new owner, in some cases, to end it. Your notary can tell you where your leases stand.
A long lease with a tenant who has paid for years supports your price. A verbal lease, late rent or a tenant talking about leaving pulls it down. Put the leases in writing and bring them up to date before the sale.
Value: two incomes that are not worth the same
A mixed-use building is valued like any income property: net operating income divided by a capitalization rate drawn from comparable sales. The difference: buyers do not capitalize a dollar of commercial rent the same way as a dollar of residential rent. A vacated apartment generally re-rents faster than a commercial unit, which can stay empty for a long time. Many buyers therefore apply a more cautious rate to the commercial income.
What it means for you: a vacant unit at the time of sale weighs heavily on the price, and a stable business with a long lease supports it. Separate the income and expenses of each use clearly in your statements: a buyer will not pay for a number they cannot verify.
The buyer's financing: why there are fewer buyers
Your price depends on what the buyer can finance. Lenders look at the commercial share of the building, by floor area and by income. When it is small, the building finances roughly like a residential multi-unit. As it grows, the file shifts toward a commercial loan: bigger down payment, stricter qualification. CMHC can insure loans on mixed-use buildings, but under conditions tied in part to the residential share. Thresholds vary by lender and program.
The result: some plex buyers, including owner-occupants, cannot buy a mixed-use building. Fewer buyers and a longer review (leases, zoning, taxes) mean a mixed-use building often sells more slowly than a comparable plex. Also confirm with the municipality that the commercial use is permitted or protected by acquired rights; the buyer and their lender will ask.
Your options for selling a mixed-use building
| Route | Advantages | Limits |
|---|---|---|
| Commercial broker | Investor network, used to commercial leases | Commission, time on market, exclusive mandate |
| Residential broker | Wide public exposure | Less equipped for the commercial side |
| Direct buyer | No commission, fast offer, discretion for your tenants | One buyer: compare the net price |
Your building interests us. ImmoMulti buys plexes and 2 to 12-unit buildings on the North Shore and in Montréal, including those with a commercial unit at street level. We read the residential and commercial leases, visit once, and you receive a written offer within 48 hours, with no commission. The steps of a direct sale are covered in our guide to selling without an agent. For an offer on your building, contact us.
Preparing the sale of your mixed-use building
- Gather every lease, residential and commercial, with remaining terms, options and land-register status.
- Separate income and expenses by use for the past two or three years.
- Confirm zoning and the compliance of the commercial use with the municipality.
- Have the price allocation and GST/QST treatment set by a tax advisor.
- Estimate the tax on the sale: capital gain and depreciation recapture. Our tax guide covers the basics.
Informational content only. Not legal or tax advice. Rules and rates can change: consult a notary and a tax advisor about your building.