Selling

Pyrite, Asbestos, Vermiculite: Selling an Old Plex When the Inspection Finds Them

Home inspector checking the basement of an old plex for pyrite and asbestos on the North Shore

A plex built 40 or 60 years ago often has a bit of everything: backfill that was never tested, original vinyl tiles, loose-fill insulation in the attic. The buyer's inspector will note it. Better to know before they do what it means for your sale.

The four suspects in an old plex

None of these materials can be confirmed by eye. Each needs a specific test, and it is the test result, not the rumour, that sets the price discussion.

MaterialWhere it is foundHow it is confirmedWhat worries the buyer
Pyrite / pyrrhotiteBackfill under the basement slab, sometimes the concretePetrographic lab test (IPPG index)Heaved or cracked slab, backfill to replace
AsbestosPipe insulation, vinyl tiles and adhesive, textured ceilings, some jointsSampling and lab analysisRemoval cost if their renovations touch these materials
VermiculiteLoose-fill insulation in the attic, sometimes in wallsLab analysisMore expensive roof or insulation work
Iron ochreFoundation drain, sumpDrain inspection, orange deposits, water analysisClogged drain, water infiltration, a problem that can return

Health Canada recommends assuming vermiculite contains asbestos unless a lab analysis proves otherwise, and leaving it undisturbed. Lead paint joins the list in older buildings: according to Health Canada, a home built before 1960 likely contains some. It is mainly a problem during stripping or sanding work.

What you must disclose

The principle is the same for each material: you disclose what you know. A pyrite test report, an asbestos analysis, an inspector's note from your own purchase, a quote for the drain: if you have it, the buyer should see it.

The legal warranty of quality covers hidden, serious defects that existed before the sale, even those the seller did not know about. Pyritic backfill that makes the slab heave can be one. Intact asbestos in original tiles is not necessarily a defect: it is a material of its time, and a court would judge on the facts. When in doubt, disclose it and let your notary word the clause.

Put in writing:

  • Test results (pyrite, asbestos, vermiculite) and their date.
  • Signs observed: star-shaped cracks, bulging slab, orange deposits in the sump.
  • Work done: partial removal, encapsulation, drain cleaning or replacement.
  • What you don't know: "no pyrite test has been done" is useful information too.

Don't touch the vermiculite to tidy up

Removing vermiculite or asbestos-containing materials yourself before a visit is dangerous and can contaminate the rest of the building. Work that disturbs these materials should go to a qualified contractor who follows CNESST rules.

The effect on price and financing

The buyer works out what the problem will cost them, then takes it off their offer. For an investor planning renovations, asbestos or vermiculite raises the cost of every job. For pyrite and iron ochre, it is the cost of correction that counts.

Cautious orders of magnitude, to be confirmed by quotes: a pyrite test generally costs a few hundred dollars; replacing the backfill and slab of a basement, or excavating and redoing a foundation drain, often runs into the tens of thousands of dollars. Asbestos or vermiculite removal varies widely with the area and the containment required.

On the financing side, the buyer's lender reads the inspection report. If it shows a cracked slab, a doubtful drain or vermiculite, the lender may ask for a test, an expert report or quotes, or even hold back funds until the work is done. In an area known for pyrite, a test may be required from the start. Each condition pushes back the date at the notary.

Your options

Test before listing

If you suspect a problem, a test you order yourself removes the doubt before the buyer raises it. A negative result becomes a selling point; a positive one gives you time to get quotes. Our article on the pre-sale inspection of a plex covers the other points to check.

Fix what is simple

A drain to clean, a small asbestos area to remove: when the cost is known and limited, fixing it can pay more than the price cut it avoids. For pyrite, the correction is heavy; compare it with a negotiated price reduction. Foundation cracks follow the same logic.

Adjust the price, quotes in hand

Handing the buyer written quotes sets the amount under discussion. Without them, the buyer adds their own risk margin, often wider than the real cost.

Sell as-is, without legal warranty

You can sell at the buyer's risk, with a clause drafted by the notary in the promise to purchase and the deed of sale. It does not protect you from a known problem you concealed, which is why your declarations matter. See our guide on latent defects and the legal warranty.

ImmoMulti buys old plexes as-is

Pyrite, asbestos, vermiculite or a clogged drain: we are interested in your building. Tell us what you know, we visit and we make an offer that accounts for it, without requiring work before the sale. Ask for an offer.

Sources: Health Canada — Vermiculite; CNESST — Asbestos; Éducaloi — Latent defects. Informational content only: consult an inspector, notary or lawyer for your situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Nothing forces you to run a test no one is asking for. But if the slab shows cracks or the area is known for the problem, the buyer or their lender will ask for one. Doing it yourself gives you the result before the negotiation.

Disclose what you know: the age of the materials, original tiles or pipe insulation, work done. You don't have to claim there is asbestos without a test, but don't claim there is none. An honest note such as "original materials, not tested" protects you better than silence.

It weighs mostly on a buyer who plans to redo the roof or insulation, since removal must go to a specialized contractor. Left in place and undisturbed, it poses little risk according to Health Canada. The effect on price therefore depends on the buyer's plans and the cost of removal.

Yes, if they discover a serious hidden defect that existed before the sale, even if you did not know about it. They must notify you in writing within a reasonable time after discovering it. A sale without legal warranty limits that risk for what you didn't know, not for what you concealed.

Yes. You disclose the test result and the condition of the slab, then adjust the price or sell without legal warranty to a buyer who accepts the risk. A direct buyer who knows these files buys with the cost in mind, without requiring the work before the sale.

An old plex with surprises in the basement?

Pyrite, asbestos, vermiculite or iron ochre: ImmoMulti buys plexes as-is on the North Shore and in Montréal, with no broker and no commission. Tell us what you know and we make an offer accordingly.

Get a purchase price →